Our authors

Our Books
More than 865 authors
from all continents

Historical Origins of International Criminal Law
Historical Origins of
International Criminal Law

pficl
Philosophical Foundations of
International Criminal Law

Policy Brief Series

pbs
Concise policy briefs on policy challenges in international law

Quality Control
An online symposium

Our Chinese and Indian authors

li-singh
TOAEP has published more than 80 Chinese and Indian authors

atonement
Art and the ‘politics
of reconciliation’

Integrity in international justice
Symposium on integrity
in international justice

HomeIcon  FilmIcon  FilmIcon  CILRAP Circulation List TwitterTwitter PDFIcon

Element:

5. The perpetrator deported or transferred one or more persons to another State or to another location.

"There are two general grounds under international law according to which displacement of persons is legitimate: it may be carried out either for the security of a civilian population or for imperative military reasons. In either case, the chief distinction between an illegitimate forcible displacement and a permissible evacuation is that, in the case of the latter, "persons thus evacuated [are] transferred back to their homes as soon as the hostilities in the area in question have ceased." It is therefore unlawful to use evacuation measures as a pretext to forcibly dislocate a population and seize control over a territory."[1]

"[T]he jurisprudence of the Tribunal indicates that an agreement concluded by military commanders or other representatives of the parties in a conflict per se cannot make a displacement lawful. Such agreement per se 'does not have any implications on the circumstances under which transfer is lawful. Military commanders or political leaders cannot consent on behalf of the individual.' In addition, the assistance by humanitarian agencies, such as UNPROFOR, ICRC, and NGOs, in facilitating displacements, does not of itself render an otherwise unlawful transfer lawful. The determination as to whether a transferred person had a genuine choice is one to be made within the context of the particular case being considered."[2]

5.1.1. Evidence of deportation.

5.1.2. Evidence of transfer.

5.1.3. Evidence of displacement applicable in both deportation and transfer

Footnotes:

[1] ICTY, Prosecutor v. Šainović et al., "Judgement", IT-05-87-T, 26 February 2009, para. 166.

Lexsitus

Lexsitus logo

CILRAP Film
More than 530 films
freely and immediately available

CMN Knowledge Hub

CMN Knowledge Hub
Online services to help
your work and research

CILRAP Conversations

Our Books
CILRAP Conversations
on World Order

M.C. Bassiouni Justice Award

M.C. Bassiouni Justice Award

CILRAP Podcast

CILRAP Podcast

Our Books
An online symposium

Power in international justice
Symposium on power
in international justice

Interviewing
A virtual symposium