Our authors

Our Books
More than 865 authors
from all continents

Historical Origins of International Criminal Law
Historical Origins of
International Criminal Law

pficl
Philosophical Foundations of
International Criminal Law

Policy Brief Series

pbs
Concise policy briefs on policy challenges in international law

Quality Control
An online symposium

Our Chinese and Indian authors

li-singh
TOAEP has published more than 80 Chinese and Indian authors

atonement
Art and the ‘politics
of reconciliation’

Integrity in international justice
Symposium on integrity
in international justice

HomeIcon  FilmIcon  FilmIcon  CILRAP Circulation List TwitterTwitter PDFIcon

Element:

6.a. [Mental element for Element 5] [Conduct of inflicting severe physical or mental pain or suffering upon one or more persons]: The perpetrator meant to engage in the infliction of severe physical or mental pain or suffering upon one or more persons.

ICTY

In the Prlić and al. case, the Trial Chamber said:

"The mental element of this offense requires that the perpetrator acted with the direct or indirect intent to commit cruel treatments. According to the Chamber in the Limaj case, the perpetrator acted with the indirect intent to commit cruel treatments when he was aware that cruel treatments would be the probable consequence of his conduct, and he accepted that fact." "[1]

ICTR

The Trial Chamber in Ntagerura et al. stated that:

"The Chamber has no doubt, however, that the soldiers' mistreatment of the detained refugees was intentional and that, because of its long duration and the way it was carried out, it caused serious physical suffering to the victims. Consequently, the Chamber finds that this mistreatment constituted cruel treatment within the scope of Article 4(a) of the Statute."[2]

Footnotes:

[1] ICTY, Prosecutor v. Prlić, "Judgment", IT-04-74-T (vol. 1), 19 May 2013, para. 147 [Unofficial translation].

Lexsitus

Lexsitus logo

CILRAP Film
More than 530 films
freely and immediately available

CMN Knowledge Hub

CMN Knowledge Hub
Online services to help
your work and research

CILRAP Conversations

Our Books
CILRAP Conversations
on World Order

M.C. Bassiouni Justice Award

M.C. Bassiouni Justice Award

CILRAP Podcast

CILRAP Podcast

Our Books
An online symposium

Power in international justice
Symposium on power
in international justice

Interviewing
A virtual symposium